And the Pawnee Goddess Spirit Award Goes to … the Trans-Friendly Girl Scouts of Colorado!

For their recent stance against gender injustice, I hereby nominate the Girl Scouts of Colorado for a Pawnee Goddess Spirit Award. What’s that, you ask? On October 13, Amy Poehler’s Parks and Recreation warmed feminist hearts with an episode about the Pawnee Goddesses, a fictional girls’ scouting group so popular that the towns’ boys petition to join. After the Goddesses debate the pros and cons of coeducation in (of course) a democratic public forum, they decide to let boys in. (For more on why the Pawnee Goddesses are so amazing, check out Claire Moshenberg’s post on

Two weeks later, life imitated art when a Denver Girl Scout troop leader refused to admit 7-year-old Bobby Montoya, who was born male but identifies as a girl. Bobby’s mother told ABC News that the troop leader “humiliated” Bobby to the point of tears. But then came a laudable reversal of the troop leader’s decision from the Colorado Girl Scouts, who issued a statement in support of Bobby and all transgender youth:

Girl Scouts is an inclusive organization and we accept all girls in Kindergarten through 12th grade as members. If a child identifies as a girl and the child’s family presents her as a girl, Girl Scouts of Colorado welcomes her as a Girl Scout.

Today, it takes courage for a mainstream youth organization to take a public stance on what is, unfortunately, such a controversial social issue in this country. Unlike the notoriously homophobic Boy Scouts of America, Girl Scouts of Colorado exemplify the values of the Pawnee Goddesses: empowerment and inclusion. And for that reason they deserve the Pawnee Goddess Spirit Award. Or perhaps the merit badge for gender justice.

The Pawnee Goddess pledge goes:

I am a Goddess.
A glorious, female warrior.
Queen of all that I survey.
Enemies of fairness and equality,
Hear my womanly roar:

The Goddesses rightly recognize that anyone who identifies with those words deserves to be a part of their organization, no matter their biological sex. The Pawnee Goddesses may be a fictional feminist fantasy, but the courageous actions of the Girl Scouts of Colorado gives us hope that someday all youth organizations will welcome transgender children with open arms.

Hat tip to Kate Bigam at Jewesses with Attitude.

Photo by flickr user Marit and Toomas Hinnosaar under Creative Commons 2.0.


  1. I just wanted to say that I take issue with a certain comparison- this quotation- “Two weeks later, life imitated art when a Denver Girl Scout troop leader refused to admit 7-year-old Bobby Montoya, who was born male but identifies as a girl.” It suggests that a trans girl is the same thing as a boy, which isn’t the case. And, a slightly pickier point, Bobby Montoya was probably not so much born male as assigned male at birth.

  2. Is this post actually trying to say that Girl Scouts choosing to admit girls is analogous to a fictional, racially appropriative scouting organization from a comedy show choosing to admit boys?

  3. Charlotte says:

    This post is problematic for reasons that have been mentioned already, and I would have expected better from Ms.

  4. I wish I knew which troops were trans-friendly. I’d buy a case of thin mints and tagalongs from each. It’s called Girl Scouts (not Female Scouts or Vagina-Only Scouts), and the focus is on being an empowered girl, not being an ovulating, monthly menstruating person. Transgendered scouts aren’t there to perv on their fellow scouts. They are there to emulate their femininity and strength.

Leave a Reply to Cassie Cancel reply


Error, no Ad ID set! Check your syntax!