Obama Evolves!

It’s official. After a week of speculation about whether the White House was going to take a strong stand on marriage equality, President Obama has gone on record in support of same-sex marriage rights. After explaining how his views have changed over the years, the President said the words that many of his supporters have been longing to hear:

It is important for me to go ahead and affirm that I think same sex couples should be able to get married.

We’ve come a long way from 1996, when congress passed the Defense of Marriage Act. At that time, Illinois congresswoman Cardiss Collins said that the bill “should really be called the Republican Offense on People who are Different Act because it is nothing more than blatant homophobic gay-bashing.” She continued:

As I walk past the Republican side of the aisle, I expect to hear something similar to an old joke from the civil rights era: ‘Some of my good friends are gay, I just wouldn’t want my son or daughter to marry one.’

That “old joke” betrayed the crass racism of whites who would claim to have black friends and then clarify just how little that friendship meant: Good enough to mention for political gains, but not full human beings you’d let your offspring marry. As the first black woman to represent a Midwest state, elected in 1973, Collins had no doubt heard this joke in her youth. She connected the dots between racism and homophobia: “My grandmother probably couldn’t envision a time when interracial marriages would be legal in America, but today they are. One kind of discrimination is just as onerous as another and neither should be tolerated.”

Earlier this week Joe Biden made waves by saying that he is:

absolutely comfortable with the fact that men marrying men, women marrying women, and heterosexual men marrying women are entitled to the same exact rights. All the civil rights, all the civil liberties.

Commentators parsed his every word to see how it lined up with the “evolving” views of the President and by extension the Democratic party. Then when Secretary of Education Arne Duncan spoke even more emphatically in favor of marriage equality, speculation only intensified about how to interpret his views: one man’s opinion, an orchestrated attempt to curry favor with lesbians and gays or a new direction for the White House.

Back in 1996, members of Congress in the House debate on DOMA felt quite free to call homosexuality “immoral,” “depraved,” “unnatural,” “based on perversion” and “an attack upon God’s principles.” In the Senate, Jesse Helms said that the critics of DOMA were “demanding that homosexuality be considered as just another lifestyle–these are people who seek to force their agenda upon the vast majority of Americans who reject the homosexual lifestyle.”

America as a whole has evolved since then. According to a Gallup poll released this week, almost two-thirds of Democrats and half of all Americans support marriage rights for lesbians and gays. And in spite of the success of marriage bans as ballot initiatives, such as yesterday’s passage in North Carolina of Amendment One, the courts (herehere, here, and here), have found that marriage bans are precisely what Representative Collins said DOMA was back in 1996: a form of discrimination against gays and lesbians. These days, politicians tread carefully when they talk about homosexuality in general. You don’t hear anyone denouncing gays and lesbians as immoral on the campaign trail. Mitt Romney could have a gay campaign spokesperson, but under a Romney administration a gay man couldn’t marry his same-sex partner. Rick Santorum has said he has gay friends, and Sarah Palin famously had at least one.

Now President Obama has shown us what friendship really means. Civil unions, he made clear in his comments today, just aren’t the same thing as marriage. Mr. Biden expressed it best: “What this is all about is a simple proposition,” he said, “Who do you love? And will you be loyal to the person you love?”

Love and loyalty. Two qualities we all seek in our spouses, in our friends—and in our leaders. President Obama has shown true leadership today. For politicians who still want to say “I have gay friends, but” this administration has drawn a new line in the sand. When it comes to equal rights, you can’t have it both ways.  No joke.

TAKE ACTION: Click here to send a note of thanks to President Obama for showing his support for gay marriage.

TOP: Image of President Obama from Flickr user TijsB under Creative Commons. RIGHT: Photo of Cardiss Collins from Wikimedia Commons.

Audrey Bilger is coeditor (with Ms. Senior Editor Michele Kort) of the new Seal Press anthology Here Come the Brides! Reflections on Lesbian Love & Marriage, an exploration of how the legalization of same-sex marriages has irrevocably changed the way lesbians think about their unions and their lives.


  1. I always like the information NOT in articles. While I’m glad the President stepped up, let’s not paint his words and DOMA so broadly.

    1) This article clearly shows that Republicans were the one who pushed, voted, and signed DOMA into law. Not true. First, neither the House nor Senate were supermajority Republicans. Thus, Democrats also voted for the law. 32 Democratic Senators and 188 Democratic Representatives voted in favor of DOMA. Also, it was Bill Clinton (Dem) who signed it into law.

    2) While I appreciate what the President said, he really hasn’t stepped up. It’s all smoke and mirros. He is coy and being political. He said gay marriage is being settled by the States and that’s how it should remain. Thus, he is NOT saying he would repeal DOMA or sign a law making gay marriage legal. He is simply saying, “Hey States. I don’t want to get involved so do your thing. I’m not going to make sweeping federal legislation about this so no one can blame me if gay marriage is legal or not legal.” It’s political obviously because at the same time he is saying it’s a State issue (which is is NOT) he is perfectly fine not defending DOMA on a federal level and would be fine letting Courts (not Executive) declare it legal. So he gets support (money wise) but is still holding back so as to not rub Independents and religious individuals the wrong way.

    While this is progress, it’s not what everyone is making it out to be.

  2. Obama was for Gay Marriage in 1996, too. Then, he was against it. Now, he takes Dick Cheney’s stance: Let the states decide.

    Progress? Ask North Carolina.

  3. How does the LGBT community feel about drones and bombs being dropped on innocent children, women and men across the planet?

  4. What he’s saying, in effect, is that the state has no business in the bedrooms of the nation. (Canadian Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau said it first, several decades ago.)

    I’ll drink to that!

Speak Your Mind


Error, no Ad ID set! Check your syntax!