Arrest the Midwife, which premiered at SXSW last year, will receive a limited theatrical release at Atlanta’s Tara Theater from July 31 through Aug. 6. It will premiere nationwide on PBS’ POV on Aug. 31.
Elaine Epstein’s film follows Elizabeth Catlin, a beloved certified professional midwife in a small town in upstate New York. Here, Mennonites have a significant presence, and it’s common to see these “plain people” in their simple clothes (usually solid, dark colors) riding in horse-drawn buggies.
Though not Mennonite herself, Catlin developed a good reputation among this community, whose conservative Christian way of life discourages birth control and encourages at-home births outside of a hospital setting. She’s assisted with hundreds of births, including almost half of all Mennonite births each year.
In October 2018, Catlin transported a laboring woman to a hospital in Canandaigua, and the baby was born but died hours later of sepsis. Despite the family’s indication they did not blame Catlin or wish to see her prosecuted, and despite the birth taking place in a hospital, Catlin was arrested in 2019 and indicted on 95 felony counts, including criminal homicide and unauthorized practice of midwifery.
The Mennonite community does not commonly participate in modern political life or utilize technology. But Catlin’s arrest and inability to practice midwifery went against the wishes of many in her community—leading them to organize a (handwritten) letter-writing campaign, fundraise for Catlin’s legal and professional expenses, and eventually lobby state lawmakers for the legal recognition and licensing pathway for CPMs in New York.
Director Elaine Epstein hopes viewers take away something powerful: that meaningful change is often slow, imperfect and comes from unexpected places. “We’re in a time where things are pretty bad and it’s easy to want to bury our heads,” she said. “But we have so much to learn from the Mennonites.”