Public Sector Meltdown Hits Black Women the Hardest

Middle-class black Americans are among those hardest hit by the recession, in part because they were more likely to be employed in public sector jobs, the New York Times reported on Tuesday:

Though the recession and continuing economic downturn have been devastating to the American middle class as a whole, the two and a half years since the declared end of the recession have been singularly harmful to middle-class blacks in terms of layoffs and unemployment, according to economists and recent government data. About one in five black workers have public-sector jobs, and African-American workers are one-third more likely than white ones to be employed in the public sector.

“The reliance on these jobs has provided African-Americans a path upward,” said Robert H. Zieger, emeritus professor of history at the University of Florida, and the author of a book on race and labor. “But it is also a vulnerability.”

Public sector cuts also fall heavily on women. Overall, women are 50 percent more likely to work in the public sector than men.

That means, naturally, that black women are feeling public-sector cuts the most. Twenty-three percent of employed African American women work in the public sector,  compared to 19.8 percent of employed white women, 18 percent of employed black men and 14.2 percent of employed white men.

President Obama’s jobs bill would have provided help for unemployed public sector workers in the form of aid to state and local governments. That money would have help prevent the public sector layoffs that have devastated so many families and communities.

But so far, Congress has rejected the proposed legislation and the president is struggling to pass some of sub-components of the bill as separate pieces of legislation. Earlier this month, Congress approved Obama’s tax credit for veterans who want to start their own businesses.

Congressional Republicans are even fighting Obama on an extension of the payroll tax cut holiday, which would put an estimated $1,000 into the pockets of a typical family. This tax break targets working people, who are likely to spend the extra money quickly and stimulate the economy.

The payroll tax holiday extension would be a welcome boost for many American families, but, like the veterans tax credit, it would be a drop in the bucket. What’s really needed is major federal investment to support state and local governments coupled with direct job creation through spending on social and physical infrastructure.

For a more specific look at which kinds of legislation are necessary to help get women back to work, check out the author’s article “Jobs, Jobs, Jobs” in the new issue of Ms.! To have this issue delivered straight to your door, join the Ms. community.

Photo from Flickr user Jdlasica under Creative Commons 2.0.


  1. Great job, ABC, for making the recession all about white dudes and ignoring who has been most affected:

  2. People with disabilities are hit the hardest by this recession. They have a 13.1 unemployment rate compared to people without disabilities.

    Unlike somebody who can ‘learn’ to drive or save up money to purchase a vehicle in any functional condition, an individual with epilepsy, who is blind/visually impaired..etc cannot just take a job because they need one and it happens to be located outside of the public transit system. Therefore they cannot take the job.

    And these people do depend on the public sector for health care, vocational rehabilitation….. ‘Smaller government’ will not result in (contrary to public oppinion) less bills being passed by legislators. It does mean that programs assisting people with disabilities will either get cut or eliminated.

Speak Your Mind


Error, no Ad ID set! Check your syntax!