Dear Newsweek Editorialist: I Perceive That You Are Wrong

I would be shrugging about Kathleen Parker’s editorial (“He Says, She Says, We Shrug”) regarding the Newsweek poll on sexual harassment, but I am too busy cringing. When you lump together poll respondents who say they believe sexual harassment claims are unfair “some of the time,” “most of the time” and “all of the time” to conclude that “a majority of Americans don’t much believe in sexual harassment,” that’s just bad math and bad reporting.

I served as the Sexual Harassment Officer for the City of Chicago for 16 years and know all too well that harassment remains a widespread problem impacting workplace safety and equality for both women and men. I have listened to hundreds of accounts of harassment, ranging from graphic sexual propositions to stalking and sexual assault.

I am also acutely aware that there are rampant misconceptions about the issue, which this article does absolutely nothing to dispel. After supervising almost 1,000 investigations, I am frustrated by Ms. Parker’s misleading and overly simplistic argument that in sexual harassment cases, “perception” is everything. The conclusions of sexual harassment investigations, whether sustained or not, have to be based on evidence gathered through review of documents, the work site, handwriting, crime lab results and exhaustive witness testimony. This evidence can’t be based on mere perception; it has to stand up to the scrutiny of union grievances, administrative hearings, arbitrations and federal lawsuits. In all the complaints I handled, not one involved a book deal and most complainants never received a cent; they simply wanted the harassment to stop so they could remain on their jobs and feed their families.

Just because perception isn’t everything does not mean it is nothing. I agree with Ms. Parker that people have different perceptions of allegedly sexually harassing behavior, just as they do about many things in life. Some people perceive that exposing oneself to a co-worker or grabbing a co-worker’s breasts is just a joke, while the person to whom this is directed, more often than not a woman, perceives it as a deep personal violation. When Ms. Parker and I entered the workforce, there was a widespread perception that this behavior was something that just had to be tolerated. It was certainly not legally actionable. That has changed, and I perceive that a step forward for workplace rights.

When Anita Hill testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee during the Thomas confirmation hearings, the country experienced what many referred to as a “national teach-in on sexual harassment.” At that time I was working at the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights and vividly recall being riveted to the television with a group of other attorneys watching Professor Hill’s testimony. The serious allegations against Herman Cain could present another watershed opportunity for a publication like Newsweek to educate its readers about the development of sexual harassment law in our country, but that opportunity was missed with Ms. Parker’s editorial.

Photo of Herman Cain addressing allegations of sexual harassment at a press conference in Arizona by flickr user Gage Skidmore under Creative Commons 2.0

Comments

  1. It is important, I think, to acknowledge that Ms. Parker was raised by her father and had only brothers as she grew up. She may have unconsciously developed a pro-male bias even though she is a female. She, sadly, lost her mother when she was quite young. Not every woman has a feminist perspective, unfortunately.

  2. I just cancelled my subscription to Newsweek.

  3. Right on. The sad part is, I think that Parker’s overall point of the article was that sexual harassment is a real issue, but people do not perceive it as such. But she did a TERRIBLE job of getting that point across. It is though mainstream publications are afraid of “taking a side” or seeming radical, so they dance around what should be a clear, firm condemnation of sexual harassment.

  4. Great critique of Ms. Parker’s article! It is important that the development of sexual harassment law is recognized and better understood.

  5. Barbara Engel says:

    Thank you for a very clear rebuttal to the dim witted and dangerous article by Ms Parker. I share your disappointment that at this moment when our culture has been forced to confront the Penn State debacle where adults in authority positions ignored the safety of at risk children and refused to take the necessary steps to protect them from heinous sexual abuse… and in the Cain candidacy where sexual harassment claims are being minimized or disbelieved, we are overlooking the chance to critically explore the role and impact of sexual violence in our workplaces, our colleges, on our streets and in our homes. Its a pity we don’t have the courage and honesty to look at the violence committed daily throughout our communities and the lengths we go to ignore and deny it. Instead we just blame the victims.

Speak Your Mind

*