A California teenager is suing the state over a school funding system that leaves students in lower-income districts dealing with broken air conditioning, leaking roofs and deteriorating classrooms, while wealthier schools can more easily afford repairs.
It’s November, and K-12 students have been back in school for nearly three months. Besides a jam-packed slate of classes, homework, extracurriculars and social life, many students in underfunded districts have to worry about the school buildings themselves, where dangerous school facilities—like toxic black mold, leaking roofs and failing HVAC systems—impede their studies.
“In our schools … a lot of sinks are broken, and the drinking fountains are extremely dirty,” says Miliani Rodriguez, a teenager and the lead plaintiff in Rodriguez v. California. “The buildings are literally deteriorating. The ACs don’t work. There are times when we have to move classrooms because of it.”
Rodriguez was a 17-year-old high school senior at Coachella Valley High School in Thermal, Calif., when she sued the state last year. (She graduated this spring.) Her lawsuit—Miliani Rodriguez v. State of California, brought by civil rights law firm Public Advocates and filed in Alameda County Superior Court—seeks to address the discrepancies between school facilities and maintenance in wealthier public school districts and low-income ones.
Issues like malfunctioning air conditioning are especially a problem in the Golden State, where temperatures in parts of California are 110 degrees in August and September, and stay in the 90s well into October. In Thermal, classrooms regularly reach 85 degrees, according to the lawsuit. And with El Niño’s unusually heavy rain coming this winter, infrastructure problems like leaks and battered roofs are too urgent to ignore.
But current state law makes it next to impossible for some school districts to get funding for badly needed updates: Miliani Rodriguez v. State of California specifically challenges California’s School Facility Program, which requires public school districts hoping to upgrade their facilities, to raise 40 percent of school building modernization funds locally, before accessing a 60 percent match from the state… regardless of the school district’s location and community income level.
Rodriguez’s teacher Perla Penalber, who has taught history at Coachella Valley High School for nearly 15 years, says the building’s condition takes away from her instructional time. Because of malfunctioning air conditioning, Penalber brings her own fan from home for her classroom. During her decades at CVHS, where Penalber’s own children went, she has also dealt with issues such as broken windows and a broken door.
“It’s just nonstop issues that we experience, that other schools don’t have,” Penalber says. “It’s very frustrating as a teacher, and I can’t imagine as students how discouraging that is to come to school and not know if things are going to be working properly, or if your room is being moved.”
The fact that building repairs can differ so much between school districts in high- and low-income areas of the state seems to undercut the fundamental premise of public education: that education should be available to every child and teenager, free of charge, regardless of their family’s income or zip code.
School districts in wealthy areas have a much easier time running local donation campaigns and bond measures for repairs to their schools. They can then more easily access funding from the state.
Meanwhile, school districts in poorer or rural areas that struggle to raise local funds are left behind when it comes to receiving state funding, leaving school facilities to suffer from a lack of badly needed repairs as the gap between rich and poor school districts grows.
During her years in school, Rodriguez has dealt with everything from flooding in her art classroom, to mold and tiles lifting from the floor, to leaky trailer classrooms where teachers and students set out buckets to catch rainwater. In her science classes, many of her teachers have had to pay for lab equipment out of their own pocket or skipped some lab units entirely when there weren’t sufficient materials for all the students.
“A lot of this stuff is so normalized to me,” she explains, “but [when] I go to other schools and I realize how improved their stuff is, that’s when I’m shocked at how their facilities are much better than ours, and that’s when I feel like we can change it.”
The lawsuit is asking a state court to freeze $3 billion in school construction funding, until California updates its current school modernization funding formula, which Rodriguez argues is unconstitutional.
According to Penalber, Coachella Valley High School has a significant attendance problem, and she believes more up-to-date school facilities would show students their learning is valued and encourage more to attend school more regularly.
In California, as well as many other states, more affluent school districts receive more state funding per student than poorer districts. The COVID-19 pandemic threw many of these differences into stark relief, when better-funded districts had the resources to adapt to remote learning more quickly than their underfunded peers.
Meanwhile, statewide standardized testing requirements mean teachers and school districts are assessed based on their students’ academic performance. This kind of generalized assessment fails to take into account how basic school facilities, from restrooms to science labs, affect every single student every day, and these disparities between rich and poor school districts affect student performance.
Standardized test scores in public schools can affect local property values, while property wealth has been shown to lead to better educational opportunities in the local schools. This cycle—good test scores mean better-funded districts, which mean good test scores, which mean better-funded districts—creates a catch-22 that widens the funding gulf between rich and poor school districts even further.
Rodriguez v. California highlights the fact that the people making decisions about school funding allocations at the state level all too often don’t have experience in schools like Rodriguez’s, where facilities issues like mold in classrooms get in the way of students’ learning.
That’s all I really want out of this: just to make sure that students in schools like Coachella Valley High School have the same opportunities and learning environments as anyone else in Palo Alto or those richer districts.
Perla Penalber, teacher at CVHS
Rodriguez got her start in community activism as a freshman in high school, when she joined CVHS’ Young Women Empowerment Club, which her teacher Penalber advises, and later became the club’s president. (The Young Women Empowerment Club is a chapter of Girls Learn International, a program of the Feminist Majority Foundation, which also publishes Ms.)
Rodriguez has also been involved with the education justice branch of Alianza Coachella Valley, a nonprofit organization that involves students across Coachella Valley Unified School District. Her high school extracurriculars have all been overshadowed by the politics of the past few years. In the past, she’s helped organize an annual community music festival, but this year she and her fellow students opted to cancel it “because we were a little concerned about the ICE raids going on.”
As of now, a trial date has not been set for Rodriguez v. California, but Rodriguez’s attorneys say the trial could begin in March 2027.
Rodriguez and Penalber are hopeful that suing the state will shed light on the modernization funding issues so many schools are facing and the need to involve local communities, students and teachers in the conversations about how to solve these problems.
Rodriguez says, “We want to create something where parents [and students] feel comfortable enough to … speak out about their facilities at their school and actually get schools improved and remodeled. I’m hoping for that for all the schools out here in California.”
“I would like to see that my students have the same access to facilities that other students in their neighboring districts or in the state of California have,” Penalber says. “That’s all I really want out of this: just to make sure that students in schools like Coachella Valley High School have the same opportunities and learning environments as anyone else in Palo Alto or those richer districts.”
*
A note from Ms. editors: We want to hear from you for The Majority, a new campaign collecting stories about how reproductive freedom has enabled readers to build the lives they want and need.
Poll after poll shows a majority of Americans support reproductive healthcare access. Yet public debate overlooks the lives shaped by abortion access, contraception, IVF, miscarriage care, maternal healthcare or comprehensive sex education—countless women who chose to pursue an education, have children, not have children, protect their health and chart their own future. What’s your reproductive freedom story? Add your voice. Together, these stories will help show not only why reproductive freedom remains a majority value, but also what it makes possible.