Peggy Scott’s Wedding on ‘The Gilded Age’ Is a Triumph of Black Representation

Peggy Scott’s lavish wedding offers a rare glimpse into the lives of the Black elite and the historical stories too often left out of period dramas.

(Karolina Wojtasik / HBO)

The entire affair was swoon-inducing. The abundance of colorful flowers decorating the historic Tiffany-glassed St. Paul’s Episcopalian Church—located in my neck of the woods, across the Hudson River in Troy, N.Y., where HBO’s widely watched The Gilded Age is filmed—heightened the lushness of the elaborately gowned Black ladies and finely tuxedoed Black gentlemen present. Even the old-moneyed white women guests, Peggy’s friend Marian (played by Louisa Jacobson) with her aunts Agnes (the always impressive Christine Baranski) and Ada (Cynthia Nixon), did not seem out of place.

Why should they be? After all, the bride did meet her future husband (the dashing Dr. William Kirkland, played by Jordan Donica) at their residence during Season 3, and under the worst circumstances of racism, when a deathly ill Peggy (Agnes’ amanuensis) would not be treated by the family’s white doctor.

In stepped the handsome and capable Dr. Kirkland, who made Peggy blush, even as she faced death’s door. Their wedding is proof that shaky beginnings can produce magnificent endings.

TikTok videos and think pieces have praised The Gilded Age for its portrayal of a Black wedding that combines elegance and wealth with traditions rooted in the history of slavery: The historic Fisk Jubilee Singers serenade the bride and groom with slave spirituals, and the ceremony includes an elegant take on the tradition of “jumping the broom.” The episode stands out as an important moment in the history of Black representation on television—and we have Denee Benton, who plays Peggy, to thank for it. She advocated for her character’s wedding to appear onscreen when the showrunners had other plans.

I … would revel in a future setting where Dr. and Mrs. Kirkland’s children become the vanguards of the Harlem Renaissance in the 1920s.

(Karolina Wojtasik / HBO)

This glorious scene celebrating Black love and Black joy, which will surely be emulated at future Black weddings to come, almost did not get televised.

Almost like a … revolution!

So—was Peggy Scott’s wedding revolutionary?

The Gilded Age, created by Julian Fellowes (of Downton Abbey fame), has the great fortune of having Black women working behind the scenes. Historian Erica Armstrong Dunbar is an executive producer, along with Sonja Warfield and Sallie Richardson-Whitfield, the latter of whom directed the wedding episode, titled “Ain’t That Good News.”

Of course, the title signifies one of two songs sung at the wedding by the Fisk Jubilee Singers, led by Peggy’s cousin Ava (played by Broadway legend Adrienne Warren), but it also alludes to the other conflicts playing out among the other characters—including the old money versus new money parlor battles between Agnes Van Rhijn and her arch nemesis, Bertha Russell (Carrie Coon, portraying the ambitious wife of business tycoon George Russell), who sneakily “stole” a presidential dinner that will now take place at her residence.

These class conflicts among the elite remind us of the transformational era they are living in, which includes the up-and-coming working-class members finding their footing among them, such as former footman turned wealthy entrepreneur Jack Trotter (played by Ben Ahlers) and former lady’s maid Enid (played by Kelley Curran) now hosting a salon of avant-garde artists and other cool people of the day, and doing so through her unconventional marriage to Agnes’ son Oscar (Blake Ritson), a closeted gay man cloaking himself and his wife with a respectability undergirded by their panache.

The society rules may be rigid, but somehow their whiteness—and a whiteness that can only take shape in the U.S., versus Europe—gives them all a newfound freedom to bend the rules, if not break them outright.

… Let us have our escapist and genteel fun, with a touch of historic truths here and there … that soften the otherwise ugly racial and gender divides of history that have laid the foundations for our own present-day struggles.

This kind of freedom is much more precarious for the Black elite, as we have seen this season when Dr. Kirkland, educated at Howard, is denied practicing privileges at Bellevue Hospital and is not even permitted to see about his Black patient, who died under their reckless care. He is well-spoken, light-skinned and quite efficient. (After all, last year, he saved the life of George Russell, who had been shot, and subsequently rewarded him generously—is that how he purchased Peggy’s summer house as a wedding gift?)

(Karolina Wojtasik / HBO)

However, these qualities did not bar him from racial discrimination. Such scenes give weight to the pettiness exhibited by his mother, Elizabeth Kirkland (played to villainous perfection by Phylicia Rashad), who disapproves of Peggy because she “is not the right image” (as noted by Peggy in her genteel confrontation with her mother-in-law, when acknowledging both her colorism and classism, the latter stemming from Peggy’s self-made businessman father being a former slave).

Mrs. Kirkland may disapprove of “jumping the broom,” a tradition associated with slavery though not necessarily a relic from African traditions. She also dismisses slave spirituals as “minstrelsy,” even though the Fisk Jubilee Singers helped bring dignity and respect to this musical tradition. They even performed before the same Queen of England whose tablecloth Agnes criticized, according to the Ladies’ Home Journal article.

But Mrs. Kirkland’s views must be understood in the context of the era’s extreme anti-Black racism. Her prejudice reflects both the internalization of racist attitudes and the fragile social standing of the Black elite. She may seem vain and petty, but the larger forces shaping her disapproval make her perspective understandable.

As an aside, the executive producers understand that, after Emancipation, even former slaves were quick to discontinue such practices as “jumping the broom” when they now had access to legal and certifiable marriages. However, this specific plotline enabled some useful conversations about what defines Black American cultural traditions, and whether aspirational wealth and respectability require certain erasures of a Black experience shaped by the legacy of slavery. That this episode found such an elegant way to balance these elements through Peggy and William’s wedding, is a testament to a successful storyline grounded in a few (if somewhat bent) historical truths.

Perhaps it is only fitting that we would get a sophisticated Black wedding episode just days after the midterm elections concluded with a Mississippi win of a Democratic Senate seat in over 40 years—achieved when Scott Colom became the state’s first Black senator since the election of Blanche K. Bruce in 1874. Bruce’s marriage to Josephine Bealle Wilson in 1878 became one of the earliest elaborate Black weddings to receive national press coverage.

That our fictional Peggy is worthy to step into the historic Josephine’s role (in all her dark-skinned beauty, which does its own healing work against the colorism that abounds both in the past and today) is a vision that can only come from Black women’s efforts, on-screen and off.

We had already seen this effort at historical reclamations with Amma Asante’s Belle (2014). Asante admitted that she was pleased to anchor a Jane-Austenesque costume drama through the historical existence of the mixed-race aristocrat Dido Elizabeth Belle. It is this same historical possibility that sparked the imagination of Shonda Rhimes to adapt Bridgerton and Queen Charlotte, based on the suggestion that Charlotte, Queen of England, may have a touch of African descendancy.

While Bridgerton is speculative fantasy that dismisses all the racial and sexual mores of the Regency England era, The Gilded Age does respect historical possibilities more than historical fantasy, even when those possibilities are stretched. (For example, would Ada, growing up in old-money New York society, really consider an interracial romance, as her quick flirtation at the wedding with the dashing doctor mentor of the groom, played by Dennis Haysbert, suggests?) Bridgerton would heighten the romance, but The Gilded Age would have more genteel discretion, I would guess.

Not that interracial romances were impossible in the year 1886. It was only two years earlier that a widowed Frederick Douglass married a white woman, Helen Pitts, which scandalized both white and Black communities.

This is the era of secret interracial romances (from those navigating certain lynching in the South to individual cases like Clarence King living a double life as both the white elite of the Gilded Age and a light-skinned working-class Black man married to a Black woman in Brooklyn, made all the easier because of the segregated color line). Think also of the more common occurrences of Black people “passing for white,” such as Bella da Costa Greene, who became the prominent librarian for J.P. Morgan.

Perhaps these characters will eventually make cameos in future seasons (The Gilded Age has already been renewed for Season 5), or maybe they will have composite characters based on their histories.

There are so many stories that have yet to be told, especially Black stories that have been flattened into stereotypes, marginalized on screen, or erased altogether. A TV show heightening the simple humanity of Black women’s beauty, love and joy is still a rarity on screens both small and large.

When even this year’s biggest summer blockbuster The Odyssey can’t deliver us an unblemished Black Helen of Troy, the dolled-up Peggy Scott in all her bridal glory more than makes up for it.

Why have we become accustomed to displays of white wealth, but balk at the suggestion of its Black counterpart?

(Karolina Wojtasik / HBO)

I find it interesting how some have mumbled their slight disapproval over this representation of Black wealth as somehow unrealistic or not representative of most Black people of the era. To make such a criticism, when their white counterparts (the Van Rhijns, the Russells and the Astors) are hardly any more representative of the vast majority of white people eking out their survival in the New York City slums run by real-life Astors and whose children were getting injured in factories (as dramatized in the Settlement House scene where Marian volunteers), is to reveal one’s racial discomfort.

There are enough books about the Black elite, but they have not been routinely depicted in popular culture. Why have we become accustomed to displays of white wealth, but balk at the suggestion of its Black counterpart? And if we must get into criticisms of the elite, why can’t those not born into wealth or royalty have nice things?

This is the same sentiment that will emerge decades later, after the robber barons have broadened the gap between the rich and the poor, and working-class women take to the streets in 1912, demanding, “We want bread, and we want roses too!”

The Gilded Age is not there yet—and who knows how many more seasons will get us there? I, for one, would revel in a future setting where Dr. and Mrs. Kirkland’s children become the vanguards of the Harlem Renaissance in the 1920s!

Until then, let us have our escapist and genteel fun, with a touch of historic truths here and there, and an abundance of flowers that soften the otherwise ugly racial and gender divides of history that have laid the foundations for our own present-day struggles.

It certainly is not a stretch that a Peggy Scott Kirkland—based on real-life journalists like Ida B. Wells and Gertrude Bustill Mossell—can rise up one generation removed from slavery, to steer her own writing career with a handsome, loving doctor on her arm, all while championing women’s suffrage and anti-lynching. She’s a “founding feminist,” and her story (and her illustrious wedding) matters to us all.

You may also like:

Ensure work like this article continues
Donate Now

At Ms., we believe the stories that shape women’s lives deserve serious, sustained coverage. That’s why, since 1972, we’ve reported on gender, politics, democracy, reproductive freedom, economic justice and culture long before the mainstream press caught up. Our journalism remains independent because it is funded by readers—not advertisers, corporations or billionaires. If this story mattered to you, please consider supporting Ms. by making a tax-deductible donation, becoming a member to receive a magazine subscription, or gifting a membership to a friend. Your support helps ensure that feminist journalism not only survives, but thrives.

About

Janell Hobson is professor of women's, gender and sexuality studies at the University at Albany. She is the author of When God Lost Her Tongue: Historical Consciousness and the Black Feminist Imagination. She is also the editor of Tubman 200: The Harriet Tubman Bicentennial Project.